For who can bear to feel himself forgotten?

Every now and then I think I have to remind myself that I know nothing.

For instance, there's a spoken (sampled?) line repeated in the Bowie song, Ricochet, that runs, "And who can bear to be forgotten?"

I attributed the line to Bowie in a blog post I wrote some time ago, I seem to recall. Now I realise that this must be a quote slightly adapted from Auden's 'Night Mail' (incidentally, a poem which, for many years, unaccountably, I believed to be by John Betjeman).

The actual line, from the poem, is:

For who can bear to feel himself forgotten?

It's a fascinatingly ominous line with which to end what otherwise seems an advert for the Royal Mail.

(Note that the line in the Bowie song is not gender-specific, and is therefore more PC.)

Anyway, I'll go and flog myself now for such an egregious misconception (or, anyway, such ignorance in my attribution), though I suppose I must have known it was a quote from elsewhere, if only because of the 'sampled' quality of the words. Also… maybe I'm wrong about some of the above, too. For instance, maybe the poem was intended unambiguously as an advert, and there's no 'seems' about it (we did actually have to read this poem at school, and my recollection is that we were taught it was a kind of advert). And maybe Auden is quoting someone else.

Memory and knowledge are slippery things.

Before I go and flog myself to sleep, I'll tell you a very little about my day.

I went into Swansea and visited the Dylan Thomas Centre (incidentally, I failed to spot the Dylan Thomas reference in the title of Momus's album Ocky Milk when it came out). There I had an egg mayonnaise sandwich, a pot of tea, a chocolate brownie thing, and some salt and vinegar flavoured crisps. I noticed, on the bookshelves, a number of books about which I have recently been reading, including Piers Plowman, and, intrigued, I began to search through the shelves for any interesting finds. There were, in fact, a great many interesting books. I ended up, rather extravagantly, I'm afraid to say, buying four whole books. They were as follows:

The Mabinogion (Penguin paperback, new)
Greek Pastoral Poetry (Penguin paperback, second-hand)
The Turn of the Screw and other short novels, by Henry James (Signet Classic paperback, second-hand)
Far-Off Things, by Arthur Machen (The New Adelphi Library, second-hand)

One or two people reading this may know that I wrote a story called 'Far-Off Things'. At the time I wrote it, I was actually ignorant of the fact that Machen had written anything under the same title (I have this problem with titles). I wanted to call my story 'Unhappy Far-Off Things', but Lord Dunsany had already used that title. As far as I was concerned, the title was a quote from Wordsworth's poem 'The Solitary Reaper'. I suppose Dunsany was quoting Wordsworth, too. I'm guessing that Machen was also quoting Wordsworth for his title, but 'Far-Off Things' is a brief enough phrase that it might not necessarily be an allusion to the poem. Still, I suppose it is. And maybe Machen had the same problem as me, and had meant to use 'Unhappy Far-Off Things', but was thwarted by Lord Dunsany getting there first.

Please excuse my excessive concern with things that don't matter. I want you to know that I know they don't matter. It concerns me.

I've said this before, but sometimes it's actually a relief to think that I'll be forgotten.

3 Replies to “For who can bear to feel himself forgotten?”

  1. i think it would make a fascinating book. to collect ‘imitation is the best flattery’ examples and or, coincidences of phrases. like proust titling “remembrance of things past”, bowing deeply to shakespeare… sonnett 30 “when to the sessions of sweet silent thought i summon up remembrance of things past”.there must be thousands of even intentional lifting.i can do it a bit with art… the innovators versus the influenced.i suppose that a computer could crawl through all literature and come up with duplicates…now, your day at swansea makes me envious. i have always loved dylan thomas. what a funny little voice…. joanna newsom has.and happy reading. it’s good to walk out of a bookstore with four books. the mabinogion… read that about thirty years ago…. can’t remember a thing except that i devoured it.i am a serious gatherer of stories around the world. it goes back to my father reading mallory and chaucer to us at bedtime. of course he read tarzan and sherlock holmes also.i want to read it again. umm this guy seems to have been a bit forgotten too…

  2. Audenophile writes:”The Night Mail” wasmade in 1936, and is about the state-owned General Post Office, so it’s not simply an advert. It is celebration of a delivery service, which was, at that time, generally regarded as the best in the world. It is not intended to increase profits for anyone – the intended audience wouldn’t have been able to choose any alternative even if they wanted to. It is, I suppose, a form of state propaganda. I don’t know why that should make me like it more, but it does.

  3. i think it would make a fascinating book. to collect ‘imitation is the best flattery’ examples and or, coincidences of phrases. like proust titling “remembrance of things past”, bowing deeply to shakespeare… sonnett 30 “when to the sessions of sweet silent thought i summon up remembrance of things past”.Yes, and such a book would also help one in saying things like, “Actually, that quote originally comes from…”now, your day at swansea makes me envious. i have always loved dylan thomas. what a funny little voice…. joanna newsom has.Yes, I love her voice. Of course (?) the song is not about the Swansea in Wales, or I don’t believe it is. I think there are about six Swanseas in the U.S. and I think that about four of them are former mining towns. I might be wrong.and happy reading. it’s good to walk out of a bookstore with four books.Yes, and this was after I’d put back a number that I wanted to buy. I limited myself to four. “The Night Mail” wasmade in 1936, and is about the state-owned General Post Office, so it’s not simply an advert. It is celebration of a delivery service, which was, at that time, generally regarded as the best in the world. It is not intended to increase profits for anyone – the intended audience wouldn’t have been able to choose any alternative even if they wanted to.

    It is, I suppose, a form of state propaganda. I don’t know why that should make me like it more, but it does.Thank you. I wonder where the best postal service in the world is now. I’d find it hard to believe that it was still the British Post Office. If you’re an Audenophile, you might find something of interest here:http://www.markmcguinness.com/Some Auden minutiae:http://www.markmcguinness.com/index.php/auden-fall-of-rome/

Leave a Reply